The casting couch is that murky body of water upon which every film industry floats. Bollywood and India’s other regional film industries have had splashes of this dirty water on its sparkling walls every once in a while. Allegations, scandals, protests like the one Telugu actress Sri Reddy has launched, and the diplomatic ‘no comment’ when asked about sexual exploitation—we’ve seen it all.
Even the somewhat pristine façade of Hollywood came crumbling down with Harvey Weinstein, as #MeToo and #TimesUp delivered one punch after another to reveal the decay within.
And now choreographer Saroj Khan too has supplied her two pence about the casting couch in Bollywood. Though, fair warning, you’re not going to like what she has to say.
In an interview with a news channel, veteran choreographer Saroj Khan has defended Bollywood and the rampant casting couch in the industry, claiming that at least, the casting couch provides its victims with a source of livelihood.
Khan draws upon an unnecessary comparison with other institutions like the government, and how they “rape and leave you,” as opposed to Bollywood, which despite the casting couch, at least is a source of livelihood.
Veteran Choreographer Saroj Khan gave a bizarre justification of prevailing casting couch situation in the film industry, claiming that 'casting couch at least provides livelihood' pic.twitter.com/Gh0FguJJ0s
— TIMES NOW (@TimesNow) April 24, 2018
“If you have the art, then why would you sell yourself? Don’t take the film industry’s name. It is our ‘mai-baap’.”
Her statement, which seems to be a clear case of foot-in-mouth, has won her many irked critics as well as few supporters who seem to agree with her blunt honesty.
Some think she has fearlessly stated the truth, without mincing her words.
1. Truth.
True… She said it rightly…. https://t.co/ZCXarfUkAm
— anil kumar p k (@pkanil145) April 24, 2018
2. Appreciated?
Such honesty. https://t.co/ehMhD3MBke
— Mohan Sinha 🇮🇳 (@Mohansinha) April 24, 2018
Majorly though, the odds are not in her favour.
Maybe her intended meaning didn’t come across clearly, but making such a statement on national television amidst the current climate on women’s issues—a rookie mistake you wouldn’t expect from a senior artist like her.
1. A new term coined?
Whoreography as defined by Saroj Khan https://t.co/edW6fvHZDD
— Kajol Srinivasan (@LOLrakshak) April 24, 2018
2. Now we’re justifying the casting couch?
#Bollywood justification of casting couch in name of livelihood. https://t.co/uQrG7hVZRw
— Kumar Manish #StayAtHome 🏡 (@kumarmanish9) April 24, 2018
3. Well done, Bollywood! NOT.
With all the respect that I have or had for this woman..this is just beyond all limits…"atleast woh rape karke chhod toh nahi deti"..well done Bollywood! https://t.co/YpSWzRyO4J
— Aditi A (@AditiAnarayanan) April 24, 2018
4. Not done, ma’am.
Such a shocking statement that too from a vateran like her. Not done. https://t.co/W4C5wEkqCW
— Mansi Shah (@mansishah1611) April 24, 2018
5. Do not compare (that is, if you are) your personal experiences with those of others and belittle theirs in the process.
बहुत ही घटिया सोच।अगर आप अपने किसी अनुभव को सार्वजनिक कर रही हैं तो जरुर करिए किन्तु इसे अन्य से जोडने का अपराध मत कीजिए@ Sarojkhan
— Dr. Anno Srivastava (@AnuPrakash18) April 24, 2018
6. Victim-blaming.
Equally angered & sad at Saroj Khan's statements. Looking at sexual harassment as an occupational hazard is also internalising victim blaming…
— Vasudha Venugopal (@vasudha_ET) April 24, 2018
7. ‘Consent’ obtained through such devious means is not really ‘consent’, is it?
IRONIC that #SarojKhan says "Casting couch provides livelihood.Taking advantage of a girl is done with her consent" while world over & esp.Hollywood, Women came out with #Metoo campaign against this ugly side of the movie industry which views women as OBJECTS to be used & abused
— Rosy (@rose_k01) April 24, 2018
8. An irresponsible statement!
https://twitter.com/minimathur/status/988636551440723973
However, it looks like the veteran dance master of the celebs has taken a u-turn. In the wake of the severe criticism, Saroj Khan has now apologised for her statement.
#UPDATE – I apologise for my statement: Choreographer Saroj Khan to CNN-News18 on her statement defending casting couch. pic.twitter.com/cMB6d0QopR
— CNNNews18 (@CNNnews18) April 24, 2018
As for her critics, they’ve decided to find humour in in her retraction already:
Saroj Khan : There is nothing wrong with the casting couch
Media : WTF?
Saroj Khan : pic.twitter.com/RrlEYTsy3h
— Karan Talwar (@BollywoodGandu) April 24, 2018
There are many who’ve lauded Khan for at explicitly addressing the controversial and almost always avoided issue of casting couch in Bollywood. However, once again, her ‘good intentions’ have been marred by a rather poor choice of words and way of delivering them. A coating of tact would’ve been nice, ma’am.