- 3.4Kshares
- Share
- Tweet
- Facebook Messenger
We have heard accounts from people who have been victimized by Bollywood’s hierarchical operations. We have also heard from talented artists who have been ousted by the music industry which allegedly “celebrates” mediocrity.
However, author Chetan Bhagat has introduced another angle to the ills of the film industry – that which includes film critics. He went on a Twitter rant to talk about how film critics “write rubbish”, use “dirty tricks”, “act over-smart”, and have “ruined lives”.
He asked actors to stop seeking validation from the “elitist” critics who cause “mental health issues” in others.
Read his tweets here:
Sushant's last film releases this week. I want to tell the snob and elitist critics right now, write sensibly. Don't act oversmart. Don't write rubbish. Be fair and sensible. Don't try your dirty tricks. You have ruined enough lives. Now stop. We'll be watching.
— Chetan Bhagat (@chetan_bhagat) July 21, 2020
To the media organizations who hire these snob critics – it's an awful business strategy to hire elitists who don't understand India and think they are better than Indians. These brown outside – white inside people will ensure your organization goes bankrupt. Many have already.
— Chetan Bhagat (@chetan_bhagat) July 21, 2020
There is one critic who tried to destroy my career and spew venom on everything I'm associated with. He also tried his best to sink Sushant. His main hates a)self made people b) less anglicized more desi people and c)confident small town Indians. I beg stars not to patronize him.
— Chetan Bhagat (@chetan_bhagat) July 21, 2020
Indians love validation from people who speak good English. It's the ultimate compliment. That's where some critics built profile. They spoke good English but were evil people. Stop looking at them for validation. They are brown outside – white inside people who hate Indians.
— Chetan Bhagat (@chetan_bhagat) July 21, 2020
'Maa kasam, mazaa aa gaya aapki mast picture dekh ke.'
'Holy heavens. I was in ecstasy watching your sublime movie.'
Both lines essentially mean the same. But most Indians, even biggest stars want to hear the second. Hence,the vile critics became important.
Put an end to this.
— Chetan Bhagat (@chetan_bhagat) July 21, 2020
Dear stars,
You make tens, maybe hundreds of crores. A country of a billion people loves you. Isn't that enough? Do you really need validation from phony, English speaking evil critics, who caused mental health issues leading to a star's death? Stop patronizing them, please.
— Chetan Bhagat (@chetan_bhagat) July 21, 2020
Many excellent film critics on radio, YouTube and blogs but are not given as much importance as phony, la-di-da English speaking ones.
The British left in 1947. Just FYI.
— Chetan Bhagat (@chetan_bhagat) July 21, 2020
Several film critics reacted to Bhagat’s claims. They condemned him for trying to threaten them and stopping them from doing their work. Meanwhile, people online were left divided. While some agreed to what he had to say, others said that constructive criticism is important for films to improve.
And as a public figure, you think it's okay to threaten professionals for doing their job? YOU need to tweet sensibly first. You are just playing to the gallery. Shame on you
— Shomini Sen (@shominisen) July 21, 2020
“Don’t act over smart” 🤣 okay Chetan
— Sucharita Tyagi (@Su4ita) July 21, 2020
आप ही लिख के आदर्श समीक्षा पेश कर देना। गज्जब मूर्खता है आप की।
— MrB (@brahmatmajay) July 21, 2020
By such pressure even good film critics can't say about a film anything🙄@chetan_bhagat yes people should watch last film of #SushantSinghRajput but after watching film giving views about a film is right of audience.
That's unfair to tell them to not to put their true opinion.🙏— Dr.Deepa Sharma (@deepadoc) July 21, 2020
This makes no sense. If it's not a good movie, why shouldn't critics say that, you are trying to create an atmosphere of intimidation so that honest critics get trolled if they say anything not neutral or positive about the movie.
— Tanzila Anis. (@aaliznat) July 21, 2020
Very sensible @chetan_bhagat
If only critics can see themselves in the actors shoes ,they will see hard work , sincerity , intent and most instantly humbleness
From the trailer and his journey it is evident #DilBechara and #shushantsingrajput will be immortal pic.twitter.com/McLbDKU8bX— humblemumble2k (@humblemumble2k) July 21, 2020
Critics don't matter any more. In fact, since long. Have seen innumerable films panned by these idiots…and I actually loved them.
They give stars to stars who pay. Period. They rob the dignity of hard work. They're really useless.— EkChidiya (@mainamausi) July 21, 2020
Well that’s a strange message! I do understand the part of writing sensibly as constructive criticism is important. Else, wouldn’t there be an inherent complacency, if everything is applauded. As far as Sushant’s performance is concerned he has proved his merit multiple times.
— Anshika Sinha (@AnshikaSinha132) July 21, 2020
Chetan Bhagat then responded to each critic individually. Here’s what he said:
Elitist snobbery: Exhibit I
Talentless, mean spirited people who only had the fortune of learning English and grew up in an English speaking environment and now feel superior and constantly mock other Indians. These are the people responsible for creating a bullying culture. https://t.co/i6elepl5He
— Chetan Bhagat (@chetan_bhagat) July 21, 2020
Ma'am, when your husband publicly bullied me, shamelessly collected all the best story awards, tried denying me credit for my story and drove me close to suicide, and you just watched, where was your discourse? https://t.co/CeVDT2oq47
— Chetan Bhagat (@chetan_bhagat) July 21, 2020
This tweet is only directed to the snob and elitist critics. So you can guess who is getting triggered by it. I only said be fair and sensible. Don't try dirty tricks. Why are they getting upset?
PS: I do like fair, regular, down to earth critics and often read their work. https://t.co/HwiknublQu
— Chetan Bhagat (@chetan_bhagat) July 21, 2020
Elitist snob Exhibit 3:
Normally, this guy would be talking about the importance of mental health. But has no issues writing this about me in public, because his ilk allows that.
Also, again a talentless person who can't write one engaging paragraph certifying India's #1 writer. https://t.co/e09s85Kl31— Chetan Bhagat (@chetan_bhagat) July 21, 2020
I am obviously not holding her responsible. But she kept quiet then and is pontificating to me now. You know words like uncouth, doesn't automatically mean you understand what I said. https://t.co/jbTTpFrj4n
— Chetan Bhagat (@chetan_bhagat) July 21, 2020
Your bio tells who you have worked for before. Interesting. Anyway, I have not threatened anyone. I am simply addressing snobs and elitists and telling them not to play dirty. Again, read sensibly. Don't get rattled. https://t.co/IrcPMjkV1w
— Chetan Bhagat (@chetan_bhagat) July 21, 2020
Absolutely bro. Did you read the fair and sensible? Dirty tricks are not a part of your patronising questions btw. https://t.co/TGu4gMxQar
— Chetan Bhagat (@chetan_bhagat) July 21, 2020
Because I am awesome.
Because I threaten the elitist ecosystem.
If I win, any Indian can win. What will the elitists do then?And yes, none of these haters have been able to write one worthwhile engaging page in their life. https://t.co/2JaisHpoxT
— Chetan Bhagat (@chetan_bhagat) July 21, 2020
What do you think of this issue? Tell us!
- 3.4Kshares
- Share
- Tweet
- Facebook Messenger